If you’ve ever wondered why college in the U.S. costs so much, you’re not alone. The price of higher education in America is staggering compared to other developed countries. From tuition hikes to administrative bloat, multiple factors contribute to this financial burden on students and families. Let’s break down why college is so expensive—and whether the investment is truly worth it.
America Spends More on Higher Education Than Almost Any Other Country
Between student contributions and government support (such as loans, grants, and other financial aid), the U.S. spends about $36,274 per university student each year. This figure is notably higher than the OECD average of $20,500 per student at the postsecondary level[1].
Where does all this money go? Well, at private universities, about three-quarters of the money covers core educational operations, mainly faculty and staff salaries, student services, and research[2]. Unlike manufactured goods, college is a service, meaning its costs do not decrease with economies of scale. The high price of labor in the education sector is passed directly to students and their families in the form of tuition.
The Unusual Structure of U.S. Higher Education
Another reason college is so costly is that the U.S. operates three distinct types of institutions: public universities, private nonprofits, and for-profit colleges. Public universities, in particular, face unique financial challenges.
Public institutions depend heavily on state funding, but in recent decades, that funding has been slashed. Why? A mix of political and economic factors:
- Many states prioritize small government and resist increasing public spending.
- State governments are legally required to balance their budgets, even as healthcare costs rise.
- The 2008 recession worsened the situation, forcing further cuts.
With less government support, public universities have had to raise tuition and recruit wealthier out-of-state and international students to make up for the shortfall. For example, between 2008 and 2018, Purdue University reduced its in-state student enrolment by 4,300 while increasing its out-of-state and foreign student population by 5,300[3].
Beyond tuition, universities are locked in a competition for prestige, which drives up costs. Schools now spend heavily on non-teaching staff—lawyers, admissions officers, diversity coordinators, security personnel, and maintenance crews—making college even more expensive.
The “Arms Race” for Wealthy Students
To offset costs, many public universities began seeking out wealthier students to help subsidize lower-income students. However, this strategy quickly spiraled into a spending arms race. As schools competed for high-paying students, they built luxurious dorms, extravagant student centers, and top-tier amenities. Even private institutions joined the competition.
The result? A widening gap between well-funded schools and those struggling to keep up. Not all public universities are equally affected, as much depends on state policies and funding levels. But the trend is clear: higher education in the U.S. has become an expensive business.
A Fragmented and Complex System
Unlike countries with centralized higher education systems, the U.S. effectively operates 50 different systems—one per state—each with a mix of public, private, and for-profit institutions. This decentralized approach contributes to inconsistencies in pricing and quality.
In many ways, higher education in America mirrors its healthcare system:
- Highly market-driven and innovative, yet costly and unfair.
- Overwhelmingly complex, making it difficult for students to make informed financial decisions.
- Lower-income students, unaware of available financial aid, often apply to lower-quality schools—even though they could afford better options with the right assistance.
Ultimately, college remains expensive because no single mechanism controls price increases. Universities set tuition rates based on what the market will bear. Since a degree is still seen as a necessity for success, schools continue to raise prices, knowing that students will pay.
Does the Cost Reflect the Quality of Education?
Despite the high price tag, only a tiny fraction of students attend elite universities. The vast majority enroll in non-selective institutions. But does an American degree guarantee better skills and knowledge?
Not necessarily. Studies show that American college graduates under 35 rank below their international peers in 14 countries when it comes to practical math skills. They perform better in reading but lag behind in digital technology proficiency.
So what value does a degree actually add? On average, Americans with a bachelor’s degree earn 59% more than those with only a high school diploma[4]. But the return on investment varies:
- Associate degrees often don’t lead to significantly higher wages (about 18% more than high school graduates)[5].
- A quarter of college students drop out, often leaving with debt but no degree to show for it[6].
The Cycle of Rising Costs
College is expensive because skilled faculty and staff demand high salaries. Yet, because graduates tend to earn more money, Americans are willing to pay steep tuition prices. This allows colleges to charge even more, further increasing costs. The cycle continues, making higher education an increasingly expensive proposition.
Final Thoughts
A college degree remains a valuable asset—but only under the right circumstances. For some, a top-tier university or a high-demand major can lead to strong career prospects. For others, the cost of college may not justify the financial burden.
As tuition prices climb, students and families must carefully weigh their options. Without significant policy reforms, the high cost of college in the U.S. is unlikely to change anytime soon.
References:
[1] https://www.oecd.org/en/topics/policy-issues/education-financing.html
[2] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cue/postsecondary-institution-expense
[3] https://www.mhec.org/sites/default/files/resources/mhec_affordability_series7_20180730_2.pdf p.10
[4] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cba/annual-earnings
[5] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cba/annual-earnings
[6] https://research.com/universities-colleges/college-dropout-rates
Samidha Education Co., Ltd. 
Leave a comment